Planet Julian

This big bruiser is teaching his parents about life and love on Planet Kid.

Monday, December 06, 2004

The Dummy

There's no real reason why I've been against the dummy/ pacifier/ soother all along, even though I am. I'm not even sure why. Someone told me it was evil, long ago, and I believed them. Even though I've seen plenty of children grow up with dummies, with no ill-effect. And still, I waver.

I think part of it is that I want to believe that I don't need a dummy. That I can handle a bit of crying, that I'd rather soothe my child myself, that I don't want to create a good baby artificially. That having a dummy-less baby somehow proves I'm a better mother. (Untrue, I know.)

And yet, this week, I've had a crying baby. And had many friends who told me they solved the same problem by giving their child a dummy. With positive results. I am on the verge, but can't quite take the plunge. I have several dummies sitting in my pantry, still sealed and unsterilised, just in case I change my mind. But since Julian is already 12.5 weeks old, it seems like a shame to start now...

Why do I think it's a shame? Why have I been prepared to discard so many other views of people when it comes to babies, but can't quite shed this one?

2 Comments:

Blogger PapaDogDuvalier said...

We haven't found much use for the soother (as it's known where I come from)/pacifier (as it's known where Mama Dog comes from), mostly because Baby Dog never seemed inclined to keep it in her mouth for more than a few seconds at a time. It got kind of old continuously popping it back in. We kept thinking maybe we'd use it more when she got a little older. She's probably big enough now, but doesn't seem to need it. Maybe we'll try it some time when she's unsoothed and not pacific.

10:23 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Assvice from an infertile to follow....I was studying to be a midwife for quite awhile until infertility railroaded it so this is why I have the useless dribble to follow.

One reason that it can be not good is because when a child sucks on a bottle nipple or pacifier all of the muscles in the jaw and mouth move forward in the front of the mouth. When babies suck on the breast they latch with their whole mouth slightly open (not that I would know myself :) thus the sucking comes from the whole mouth and jaw rather than the front. The problem can be to overdevelop the muscles in front causing the teeth to come in more towards the front or possibly change speech development. There is also a much higher percentage of children who were bottle fed that eventually need braces compared to breast fed. Again I want to say that I am not judging or even really care all that much what people decide to do with their babies or children....:) no militancy here.

Now of course when children are most raised on a breast and the use of one of the pacifier things helps mom get more sleep, a quiet moment, then use it for sure..... I think this falls into the category of all the no no's that people get too high maintenance about...like your post somewhat addressed.

I wrote this post not because I am telling you to use or not to use it but just because I find it interesting in general.

alex I.G. On another note...I hope you and baby Julian are well and I continue to read...I love coming here. Thanks

6:47 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home