Planet Julian

This big bruiser is teaching his parents about life and love on Planet Kid.

Tuesday, March 01, 2005

Boys Vs Girls

A woman I know just gave birth to her second boy. When she told me she was expecting a son, she said so with some disappointment - it was clear that she thought it would be ideal if she had a boy and then a girl. I'm not even going to go into how much this mindset disturbs me, but suffice to say, for a long time, I would have been happy with a baby of any type. It didn't have to even be my biological baby, and I would've been perfectly happy with a little Chinese or Ethiopian baby. In fact, it didn't have to be a baby - if you'd given me a child of two years old to raise, I would've been pretty damn happy with that, too. The most I dared wish for, beyond a child of my own (and by "own", I mean mine to raise) was for a healthy child. To ask for anything else would've been silly, like wishing you had blue eyes if you're Cindy Crawford.

I knew I was expecting a boy when I was 20 weeks pregnant, although I suspected as much before then. I was elated, because once I was told it was a boy, it seemed exactly right, although there was a little bit of panic there, too: did I know anything about boys? Could I relate to a little person's boyhood? Would I be able to educate myself well enough?

Turns out, there was nothing to worry about. Every day, my experience with Julian is about being his parent, and about him being my child. It goes far beyond his sex, and I can't imagine it being different if he was a girl.

But, a lot of people say that raising boys and girls are fundamentally different. One friend has two daughters, and she says that when she goes out with her friends, her girls are happy to scribble drawings on a pad at the table, whereas the boys are routinely under the table chucking things at one another. Another pal with three children says that her 8 year old son wakes up on a Saturday morning and can't do anything without her - he wants her to make his breakfast and plan his day. Whereas her younger daughter, who's 5, will wake up and make breakfast for herself and the 3 year old.

There's an Australian therapist who has written a book called Raising Boys which I think claims that many people tend to do a mess of raising little men, and that a different approach is needed than the one used to raise girls. Some of the things he says, at a glance, make sense, but in the early days, I still think that parenting is fundamentally the same. You've just got to love them in bits. Everything else comes after that.

PS In other Julian-related news, Ali the pug got her first hefty kick in the face from him today. Then, for an encore, he kicked her again. She seemed to be quite sore in the face after, rubbing her eye and blinking a lot, but didn't react to him at all. Good dog!
The other thing he's been doing for a couple of weeks is lifting his arms skyward when he wants to be picked up (the baby, not the dog). I love it!

4 Comments:

Blogger Tarz said...

Must admit guilt here. When I learned of Pearl's sex at my Level II ultrasound, I was a bit disappointed. Upon hearing the sonogram technician's suggestion to "think pink," I said, "Oh." I so thought that I was having a boy; I had had dreams of giving birth to a boy, and Papa Dog & I had already picked out his name years before.

But... while pregnant, I eventually warmed up to the idea of a girl, and now can not imagine having anything else. I so love having a girl now. In fact, if I were to have another, I'd almost prefer another GIRL!

5:31 AM  
Blogger Christine said...

same here, after the amnio we learned it was a girl and I felt some disappointment. Josh's only other sibling has 4 girls, and I wanted to break in the first boy. That's the people pleaser in me I guess. I warmed to it though and then came to the easy revelation that a girl was at least familiar. Now I'm scared of a boy, though I know I would be happy with it if/when the time came - that's what the last experience taught me anyway.

Is there something to boys being different from girls in how they are immediately socialized? Of course perhaps one could make the same argument about girls being raised to be girly, but I find that men have very highly tuned radars for validating the masculinity of their male offspring. They squint in panic at the thought of a mere infant being dressed in any perceived feminine way, and monitor and encourage brutish behavior in general. Not to say that they are trying to raise little animals...I don't mean it's pernicious or deliberately agressive, but they seem to have a lot at stake in siring boys who act like boys. My husband is amusingly self-deprecating about his lack of athleticism, but he is already worried about teaching our perhaps-never-to-exist son to properly throw a baseball (Especially humiliating is that I could do it, as baseball was a serious priority to my dad so my sister and I were taught early to play like boys).

5:51 AM  
Blogger Tarz said...

Christine -- I'm starting to picture you as this 6-foot-tall Amazon jock!

Funny, Papa Dog has mused about the same thing -- being relieved that Pearl's a girl so that he doesn't have to throw around a baseball. I'm sure that if/when we were to have a boy, Papa Dog would find other ways to instill a strong sense of masculinity in the boy. Some of the greatest writers were quite macho, after all. Hemingway comes to mind.

10:05 AM  
Blogger Christine said...

I'm actually too clumsy to be athletic, but I'm a hidden asset on the occasional game of pickup softball. Until I break a finger.

That Hemingway masculine writer thing is exactly what josh is going for too. I think he has it, especially now with a beard.

11:48 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home